Entries
| Year |
Winner |
Dish Type |
| 2007 |
Dave Anderson |
Chili |
| 2008 |
T.J. Spilman |
Chili |
| 2009 |
Unknown |
Chili |
| 2010 |
Unknown |
Chili |
| 2011 |
Kristin Krowiorz |
Chili |
| 2012 |
Jerry Ader |
Chili |
| 2013 |
Troy Kohl |
Chili |
| 2014 |
Troy Kohl |
Chili |
| 2015 |
Tyler Plog |
Chili |
| 2016 |
Brent Schuettpelz |
Chili |
| 2017 |
Kristin Krowiorz |
Chili |
| 2018 |
Dan Baumann |
Chili |
| 2019 |
Patrick Dewane |
Chili |
| 2020 |
Mitch Huenink |
Chili |
| 2021 |
Adam Posegate |
Chili |
| 2022 |
Adam Posegate |
Chili |
| 2023 |
Troy Kohl |
Chili |
| 2024 |
T.J. Spilman |
Chili |
| 2024 |
Erika Zakrzewski |
Soup |
| 2025 |
Kyle Jansen |
Chili |
| 2025 |
Baylei Baltus |
Soup |